Monday, February 14, 2005

Getting Started

I am actually embarking on an adventure in writing and publishing. It is quite a new experience for me to put myself and my views "out there," beyond the comfortable walls of my classrooms and the protective embrace of my institution. While I am known among friends and colleagues as a rather opinionated broad, I am not usually so bold as to be opinionated in such a public way.

I am hoping that writing a blog will help me reach a few of the goals, as a teacher and scholar, I have not accomplished yet. Most importantly, I hope that this kind of writing will help me get over my collossal writer's block and give me the confidence to believe that what I have to say actually makes sense and is interesting to others.

Higher Education is a good mother; she allows us a lot of freedom in putting our ideas before the world. But she also is rather strict about what counts as legitimate scholarly inquiry and what does not. The gap that emerges then between academic freedom of expression and accepted academic forms of expression has expanded rather than contracted over the last few years, despite new forms of publishing. Internet publishing outlets, such as websites, e-zines, and blogs, are not considered to be credible venues for scholars to present their thoughts. Scholars must prove the value of their contributions to each other first before these contributions are allowed to become part of a shared conversation. But it is not the idea of peer review itself that scares me and has kept me from writing--after all as a teacher I ask students all the time to present their ideas to their peers for consideration and comment, so I should be able to practice what I preach--it is the pressure to work with and integrate a certain theoretical orientation and thinking that makes writing in the academic context a hated chore for me.

In order for a paper to be acceptable to a reviewer and editor it has to offer more than random exploration. It has to ask and possibly answer a central question, make a preferably innovative point, connect with the theory of the field, make an original contribution, be academically rigorous, ... etc. Much of my thinking though will never be publishable in peer-reviewed academic journals, and even those ideas that could make it into one of these journals are not yet to the point where they actually can. I am a great believer in random exploration, in making strange connections across seemingly unrelated areas, in thinking and arguing by indirection and implication, in taking the long way to an answer. I hope to be able to do this kind of thinking and writing here in my blog.

And of course, I need a place to vent--perchance to rant--about the many things that do not seem to make any sense right now. Maybe I will find others who are willing to share their experiences and thoughts with me and start a dialogue that will help us to make new connections. Maybe I will talk to myself for the most part, but I hope not. Conversation, dialogue, exchange... I believe in those things because they can draw us together and help us connect the dots.